Massachusetts Clergy Abuse Report Counts 944 Survivors

âš¡ TL;DR
Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell released a 203-page report on Sept. 30 counting 275 accused clergy and 944 survivors in the Fall River, Springfield and Worcester dioceses. Only one criminal case resulted, largely because of old laws and expired time limits, and Campbell is urging lawmakers to lift the statute of limitations.

Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell on Wednesday, Sept. 30, released a 203-page clergy abuse report finding that more than 270 Catholic clerics abused nearly 1,000 children in the dioceses of Fall River, Springfield and Worcester over several decades. The findings close a state investigation opened in 2019 under then-Attorney General Maura Healey, now the state’s governor.

clergy abuse report

The report counts 275 accused clergy and 944 survivors. Campbell described it as the first full public accounting of abuse and institutional failures at the three dioceses, which sit outside the Archdiocese of Boston, where a separate scandal broke open in 2002.

Inside the clergy abuse report: 275 accused, 944 survivors

According to figures released by the attorney general’s office and reported by NBC Boston, the totals break down by diocese as follows:

  • Fall River: 92 accused clergy and 469 survivors
  • Springfield: 93 accused clergy and 259 survivors
  • Worcester: 90 accused clergy and 216 survivors

The report noted that its count of accused clergy was not filtered by an assessment of whether each individual allegation was credible, and that the true scope of the abuse may never be known. Investigators reviewed more than 300,000 pages of documents and interviewed more than 100 people. WBUR reported that the documented abuse dates back to the 1950s, and Reuters reported that most of it occurred before 2002.

“Behind every one of those numbers is a child whose safety was violated, a family that was changed forever and a survivor who carried that abuse for years, and in many cases decades,” Campbell said at a press conference in Boston.

How church leaders handled warning signs

The report documents accused priests being transferred to other parishes without explanation, priests returned to ministry after treatment without proper supervision, and allegations that were never reported to law enforcement.

“For years, the dioceses of Fall River, Springfield and Worcester knew that children were being abused by priests, and they did not do what they should have done to stop it. Instead, too often they protected the reputation of the church rather than protecting children.”

In one case, after the church received a report in 2006 that a priest had abused a child, the person who came forward did not hear back for 13 years. During that time the priest remained in service without restrictions, even chaperoning overnight school trips in 2008, 2009, 2012 and 2013. A second report about the same priest arrived in 2014, but the diocese took no action until 2020. He was ultimately suspended and removed from ministry.

Why almost no one was charged

Campbell’s office made three referrals to local district attorneys, and one case referred to the Worcester District Attorney’s Office led to charges in district court.

“Some of the conduct we identified was not a crime under Massachusetts law at the time the incident occurred. We cannot apply a criminal law retroactively. In other cases, the statute of limitations had already expired,” Campbell said. Her office left open the possibility of future prosecutions where charges can still legally be brought.

The report does not publish a comprehensive list naming all 275 accused clergy, and many individual cases are described without identifying the accused. That choice drew criticism from survivors and from the watchdog group BishopAccountability.org, whose codirector Anne Barrett Doyle said, “We still have bishops keeping secrets.”

Fall River, Springfield and Worcester bishops respond

All three dioceses issued statements on Wednesday. Fall River Bishop Edgar M. da Cunha apologized directly to survivors: “To all survivors of child sexual abuse, I am deeply sorry. We as a Church failed you when you were most vulnerable.” He said the diocese gave investigators more than 80,000 pages of documentation and published a list of clergy facing credible accusations five years ago.

Springfield Bishop William D. Byrne called the findings “a humbling reminder of the need for continued vigilance in properly handling all instances of child sexual abuse when reported to us,” and said his diocese welcomed the attorney general’s recommendations.

The Diocese of Worcester said it would study the report “to identify any additional improvements that can be made to respond to victims of past abuse and to continue to strengthen efforts to keep children safe.” Campbell singled out Worcester as the only diocese in Massachusetts without a public list of credibly accused clergy. The diocese defended that position, citing Vatican guidance and saying such lists “can be a cause for deep division among many members of our Church.” According to BishopAccountability.org figures cited by WBUR, nearly 92% of U.S. dioceses and archdioceses have published such lists.

For more on the Vatican’s direction, see our report on how Pope Leo signaled a shift in the Church’s emphasis.

Recommendations for dioceses and lawmakers

The clergy abuse report asks the three dioceses to take five steps, including trauma-informed handling of allegations, independent investigations, enforced restrictions on accused priests and public access to information about credibly accused clergy.

Campbell also asked the Legislature to act. Her office’s recommendations include:

  • Eliminating the $20,000 charitable immunity cap for civil claims involving child sexual abuse
  • Eliminating the statute of limitations for civil claims involving child sexual abuse
  • Creating an indefinite lookback period for survivors whose civil claims have already expired

The charitable immunity cap limits damages against nonprofits such as dioceses. A bill from state Sen. Joan Lovely and state Rep. John Lawn to remove the time limit and open a “look back window” is now in a conference committee.

Survivors waited years for the findings

Some survivors interviewed in 2021 said the long wait added to their pain.”The silence that we experienced from five years of waiting isn’t neutral,” survivor David Lewcon told WBUR. Campbell rejected the idea that her office had stalled: “We never stopped working to release this report publicly. At no point were we idle.”

Campbell said she hoped the clergy abuse report would be “a meaningful step forward toward truth, accountability and healing that survivors deserve.”

0
Show Comments (0) Hide Comments (0)
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x