A leaked Ohio utility bill would change which entities qualify as public utilities and revise the process for taking private land, raising concerns about projects serving data centers. News 5 Cleveland reported on November 16 that Republican Sen. Bill Reineke of Tiffin is working on the draft, which has drawn objections from Ohio farmers and landowner advocates.

Legal experts cited by News 5 said the proposed language could allow a transmission developer to seize land to power or place a data center. Reineke and the Ohio Business Roundtable, however, said their aim is to simplify infrastructure development, not give eminent domain authority to entities that lack it.
Ohio utility bill would broaden public utility language
The draft changes the definition of a public utility, which currently covers entities owned or operated by municipal corporations, electric cooperatives and agencies holding a certificate of public convenience and necessity from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, according to News 5.
It adds an agency holding a certificate of environmental compatibility and public need from the Ohio Power Siting Board for construction of an electric transmission line and associated facilities, or a gas pipeline and associated facilities.
That language is central to the concern about who could acquire land. News 5 reported that the draft specifically changes who is considered a public utility for both electrical transmission and gas, despite supporters’ assurances that it would not extend eminent domain privileges.
The Ohio Power Siting Board controls installation of utility facilities, including power lines, some gas pipelines and wind farms. The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio can also help utility companies acquire land, News 5 reported.
Farmers warn of weaker property rights
The Ohio Farm Bureau opposes changes to eminent domain, though its representative Evan Callicoat told News 5 that the organization is not opposed to data centers. Its objection concerns property rights.
“We are aware of efforts to further erode the limited protections that landowners have, allowing for quick take of property without first paying for the property and determining a landowner’s rights and compensation through a court of law,” Callicoat said.
Callicoat feared the proposal was broad enough that farmers could lose land to data centers and wait months or years for payment. The bureau had been preparing for the dispute since June, when News 5 reported that the Ohio Business Roundtable recommended changing eminent domain law to extend possession authority to energy infrastructure projects once public use and necessity had been established.
Business group backs deposit and build
The Roundtable calls its proposed approach “deposit and build” and says it is modeled on a system used in 45 other states. Its representative Alexandra Denney said the recommendation was intended to support a reliable, affordable grid and continued economic development.
Under the process described by News 5, a utility approaches an owner with a fair-market-price offer. If the owner refuses, the utility goes to court to establish the necessity of taking the land. If the court agrees, the appraised value goes into a court account, and the owner can appeal to seek more money. Construction cannot begin while that court battle continues.
The draft would change the appraisal process, making it easier to seize land immediately, News 5 reported. Denney argued that construction delays increase costs and hold up infrastructure needed for grid reliability.
Denney knew about the appraisal provisions but denied changes to eminent domain. After the reporter read the bill aloud, she said she would need to look at the public utility definition changes.
Reineke says existing authority would not expand
Reineke, identified by News 5 as the incoming Senate president, said expanding utility infrastructure was a way to keep rates down.
“It’s important to me that landowners keep their rights, and this would not extend eminent domain to anyone who doesn’t already have that privilege — rather, it is a framework to simplify our existing process that would put us in line with 45 other states.”
The Ohio utility bill emerged after voters chose to restrict or ban data centers in 21 cities, according to News 5. Denney said those votes had nothing to do with the proposal’s timing and said the Roundtable did not intend to expand eminent domain authority.
A family farm’s experience with land seizures
For Gretchan Francis, the debate follows decades of efforts to preserve her multigenerational family farm. She told News 5 that the property is now 60 acres rather than 160, and that the state has taken portions repeatedly for highway development.
Francis said she understood that eminent domain could be necessary but believed it had to be used properly. Taking personal land for a data center, she said, would serve a corporate, private, for-profit need rather than a public one.
News 5 reported that members of the farming community planned to call lawmakers to demand that they stop the Ohio utility bill. Francis emphasized the farm’s connection to her family’s history: “I want my kids to know where they came from. It’s hard to describe when you have roots not just to a family, but to a place.”