N.M. Jury: Meta Liable for 43M Privacy Violations

âš¡ TL;DR
A New Mexico jury has found Meta liable for over 43 million violations of the state’s Unfair Practices Act tied to how Facebook handled user data and targeted minors. Under the law’s per-violation penalty structure, Meta’s exposure could top $200 billion, though a judge will determine the final award. The company says it plans to appeal.

A jury in New Mexico has found Meta Platforms liable for more than 43 million violations of the state’s Unfair Practices Act, a verdict that could expose the company to civil penalties exceeding $200 billion depending on how a judge applies the law’s per-violation fine structure. The case centered on allegations that Facebook mishandled user data and failed to adequately protect minors from predatory contact on the platform.

Meta New Mexico verdict

The verdict, delivered this week in state district court, marks one of the largest consumer protection judgments ever returned against a major technology company. New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez brought the case in 2023, arguing that Meta’s internal practices around data collection, algorithmic recommendations, and account safeguards repeatedly exposed children and teenagers to harm while violating state disclosure and fair-dealing requirements.

What the Jury Decided

Jurors determined that each instance in which Meta’s practices ran afoul of the Unfair Practices Act constituted a separate violation, producing the enormous tally of more than 43 million infractions. New Mexico law allows penalties of up to $5,000 per violation, a multiplier that pushed the theoretical maximum exposure past $200 billion — a figure that dwarfs Meta’s annual profits and would rank among the largest corporate penalties in U.S. history if upheld in full.

The state’s legal team argued that Meta’s own internal research, portions of which were introduced as evidence, showed the company was aware of risks to younger users well before regulators intervened. Attorneys for New Mexico contended that Meta prioritized engagement metrics over user safety and continued practices flagged internally as harmful.

“This verdict sends a clear signal that companies cannot treat consumer protection laws as a cost of doing business,” a spokesperson for the New Mexico Attorney General’s office said following the decision.

Meta’s Response

Meta has disputed the jury’s findings and signaled it will appeal, arguing that the per-violation calculation dramatically overstates any actual harm and that the case mischaracterized routine product decisions as deliberate legal violations. The company has previously maintained that it has invested heavily in parental controls, age-verification tools, and content moderation systems aimed at protecting younger users.

A final penalty amount has not yet been set. Under New Mexico procedure, a judge will hold additional proceedings to determine how much of the maximum statutory penalty Meta will actually owe, a process that could take months and is likely to be contested through post-trial motions before any appeal moves forward.

Part of a Broader Legal Pattern

The New Mexico case adds to a growing list of legal setbacks for Meta over its data and privacy practices. Just weeks earlier, a separate New Mexico jury also found the company liable on related privacy claims, a decision NarwhalTV covered in detail in its report on the New Mexico jury’s privacy verdict against Meta. Taken together, the rulings suggest state courts are increasingly willing to apply aggressive per-violation penalty math to tech platforms, a trend that could embolden other state attorneys general pursuing similar claims.

Meta’s legal troubles have already rattled investors. Following earlier setbacks tied to regulatory scrutiny and stock analyst downgrades, CEO Mark Zuckerberg saw billions wiped from his personal net worth, a development detailed in NarwhalTV’s coverage of how Zuckerberg lost $9 billion after a Goldman Sachs warning on Meta stock. Analysts say a multibillion-dollar penalty tied to this latest verdict, even if reduced substantially by a judge, could reignite concerns about Meta’s regulatory liabilities weighing on its valuation.

What Happens Next

Legal experts caution that the headline $200 billion figure is a statutory ceiling rather than a guaranteed outcome. Judges overseeing similar consumer protection cases have historically reduced per-violation awards significantly, weighing factors such as the severity of harm, the company’s conduct, and its ability to pay. Still, even a fraction of the maximum penalty would represent a substantial financial and reputational blow to Meta.

  • A post-trial hearing will determine the actual penalty amount owed by Meta.
  • Meta has indicated it will appeal the underlying liability finding.
  • Other states may watch the case closely as a template for future consumer protection litigation against social media companies.

The case is expected to remain in litigation for an extended period, with appeals likely to stretch into 2027 or beyond. In the meantime, the verdict adds pressure on Meta and other major platforms to demonstrate stronger safeguards for younger users amid intensifying scrutiny from state regulators nationwide.

0
Show Comments (0) Hide Comments (0)
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x